When I was a kid, “lighter” meant a Zippo or disposable Bic lighter. Now, there are many types of lighters, including types with multiple flames, electric ignition, and different fuels.
Here’s what you need to know about types of lighters, pros and cons, and what the best lighter is for your needs.
What Makes One Lighter Different than Another?
A lighter is any portable device which creates a flame, usually by igniting fuel held within its case. When dividing lighters into types, there are six key differences:
- Ignition method
- What fuel is used
- How long the fuel lasts
- Strength and directionality of the flame
- Number of flames
- Features, such as case design or waterproofness
Types of Lighters
Note that there is a lot of crossover in these types of lighters. For example, utility lighters can also be spark ignition or electric arc lighters.
1. Plastic Sparkwheel Lighters
These are plastic lighters that have a wheel made out of serrated steel. A flint is located below the wheel.
When you spin the wheel with enough speed, it rubs on the flint and creates a spark. Pressing down on the “fork” (the plastic lever below the sparkwheel) opens a valve so fuel can be released.
The spark ignites the fuel and produces a flame.
Note that many plastic sparkwheel lighters are actually refillable (see how to refill a BIC lighter). However, because they are so cheap, most people treat them as disposable.
In a SHTF situation, you can use an empty sparkwheel light to create a flame. Read about how to start a fire with no matches.
Features
Fuel type: Butane
Ignition method: Spinning a sparkwheel
Casing: Plastic
Windproof: No
Waterproof: Somewhat
Pros
- Cheap
- Flame size is usually adjustable
- Come in large and small sizes
- Sometimes are refillable
- In a pinch, can still be used when empty
Cons
- Most can’t be refilled
- Sparkwheel gets hot when lit for a long time
- Don’t work well in windy or wet conditions
- Hard to use while wearing gloves or with sweaty hands
2. Piezo Spark Ignition Lighters
This type of lighter uses a button instead of a sparkwheel.
When you press the button, it hits a quart element. Quartz is piezoelectric, meaning it creates electric voltage when hit. The electric voltage is what ignites the fuel inside the lighter.
Features
Fuel type: Butane
Ignition method: Push-button creates electric spark
Casing: Plastic
Windproof: No
Waterproof: Somewhat
Pros
- Cheap
- Flame size is usually adjustable
- Childproof models available
- Easy to light, even with sweaty hands
Cons
- Disposable
- Make a loud clicking noise
- Don’t work well in windy or wet conditions
- Not reliable – the ignition often fails
3. Zippo-Style Lighters
Zippo lighters have been around for nearly 100 years. They work by spinning a sparkwheel against a flint inside the Zippo. This creates a spark that ignites fluid in a wick.
Unlike disposable sparkwheel lighters, a Zippo wick will stay lit until you cut off the oxygen supply by closing the lid. You can even leave a Zippo burning like a candle. The downside, however, is that the eyelet which exposes the fuel-filled wick is always exposed. This can result in fuel leakage (and a nasty rash on your skin).
Air exposure means Zippo fuel will evaporate quickly. At best, expect a Zippo to last 10 days before refueling. An odd thing about Zippo lighters is that the fuel lasts longer if you use it frequently. If you don’t light the Zippo often, the fuel might evaporate in just 3-4 days.
Because Zippo fuel evaporates quickly, they aren’t recommended for camping or emergency prep. Zippos are meant for regular smokers who want a cool, personalized lighter.
While Zippo lighters last virtually forever (you can even buy antique Zippos, which work fine), the flint and wick will need to be replaced eventually.
On the plus side, Zippo fluid is made of a petroleum distillate which ignites easily and burns cleanly.
It also works better in freezing temperatures than butane lighters.
In a pinch, you can also use other fuels in a Zippo lighter, including butane, naptha (also called white gas or Coleman fuel), or gasoline.
I’ve heard of people using 99% isopropyl alcohol, methylated spirits, or Bacardi 151. However, alternative fuels aren’t recommended in Zippos because they might clog the Zippo. Some alternative fuels, like Charcoal fuel, can cause your Zippo to explode.
Note: Some cool “peanut lighters” also work the same way as Zippo-type lighters do. The benefit is that these are tiny and great for EDC. The lid sometimes screws on tightly, so there isn’t as much fuel evaporation.
Features
Fuel type: Zippo fuel but alternative fuels also work
Ignition method: Sparkwheel
Casing: Metal
Windproof: Yes
Waterproof: No
Pros
- Stays light without holding any button
- Large sparkwheel is easier to use
- Multiple fuel options in a pinch
- Refillable
- Works well in windy conditions
- Stylish
- Lifetime guarantee
Cons
- Fuel evaporates very quickly
- Often leak fuel
- Flints wear out and need to be replaced
- Require some maintenance
- Not waterproof
4. Butane Torch Lighters
Also called jet lighters, turbo lighters, or cigar lighters, butane torch lighters contain butane stored in a pressurized chamber. The fuel is forced through a nozzle with air, creating a very intense, strong, and hot flame. They are basically like mini Bunsen burners.
The benefit of torch lighters is that you can aim the flame in any direction, even upside down. Because of this, they are often used for lighting pipes. They are also often used as cigar lighters because they get hot.
As you’d expect from a lighter, which makes such an intense flame, jet torch lighters blow through fuel very quickly. How long a torch lighter will last varies drastically depending on the number of flames, size of the fuel chamber, and pressure level.
Note that torch lighters are not allowed on airplanes, even in checked luggage. Do not take one of these with you while traveling by air!
Features
Pressurized flame
Fuel type: Butane
Ignition method: Piezo or battery
Windproof: Yes
Waterproof: Usually
Pros
- Strong, hot flame
- Can point flame in any direction
- Works in very windy conditions
Cons
- Burns through fuel quickly
- Piezo ignition often fails
- Many cheap brands fail quickly
5. Electric Coil Lighter
Also called flameless lighters, these are battery-operated lighters. Electricity from the battery heats a coil inside the lighter, which can then be used to light cigarettes or other things pressed against the coils.
These lighters are easy to use, reusable, don’t require any fuel, and are usually charged via USB. However, the coils make it challenging to light anything other than a cigarette or maybe candles. They aren’t ideal for camping, emergency preparedness, or other basic uses.
Features
Ignition method: Electric
Waterproof: No
Pros
- Easy to use
- Safe
- USB chargeable
- Stylish
Cons
- Won’t ignite tinder or anything thick easily
- Charge doesn’t last very long
- Many cheap brands fail quickly
6. Electric Arc Lighter (Plasma Lighters)
These are also flameless lighters but are very different from the electric coil lighters above. With an arc lighter, high-voltage electricity makes an arc of charged plasma between two electrodes.
The plasma arc is hotter than a traditional flame and won’t be blown out by the wind. Some electric arc lighters have four electrodes to produce two arcs.
These lighters have become very popular because they work in windy conditions, require no fuel, are rechargeable, and are simply cool. Price varies drastically. Pay attention to brand reputation and battery life when choosing an arc lighter.
Read: Best Plasma Lighters For Survival
Features
Fuel type: USB-chargeable Lithium-ion battery
Ignition method: Electric button
Windproof: Yes
Waterproof: Mostly no but see below
Pros
- Windproof
- Generally very reliable
- Sleek, cool design
- No fuel required
- Easy to use while wearing gloves
Cons
- Not many lights per charge
- Battery will need to be replaced after about 400 charges
- Charge time varies; usually at least 2 hours
- Can short circuit if it gets wet
We like this one on Survival Frog; it comes in a waterproof case with a neck lanyard.
7. Permanent Match
Also known as a forever match, this type of lighter is a cross between matches and a lighter. It consists of a metal chamber that holds fuel. A spark stick with a wick inside is screwed into the chamber.
The wick absorbs fuel from within the chamber. To use the permanent match, you remove the spark stick and strike it against an abrasive striking surface on the chamber.
Permanent matches have gotten a lot of hype from the survivalist community. Yes, they are cool, and you get many more lights out of them than with standard matches. The flame is also more resistant to wind than a standard match. However, much of the info about permanent matches is a bit misleading.
For starters, most permanent matches advertise that they will last 15,000 lights. However, you will need to refuel the lighter long before this. The wick inside the permanent match will also need to be replaced. It varies depending on the brand, but don’t expect more than 100 lights before refilling or replacing the wick.
On the plus side, permanent matches have a gasket that prevents fuel evaporation. If you need something to put in a bug out bag, these can sit there for years without losing fuel.
*Important: You must blow out the “match” before putting it back in the fuel canister!
Features
Fuel type: Naptha
Ignition method: Striking like match
Casing: Metal
Windproof: Somewhat
Waterproof: Yes
Pros
- Small, cool designs available
- Fuel doesn’t evaporate
- Good for Bug Out Bags
- Waterproof
- Works decently in windy conditions
Cons
- Lots of cheap, defective ones available
- Need to refuel and replace wick fairly often
8. Candle Lighters
Also called utility lighters, this type of lighter has a very long neck. The long neck makes it easier to reach candle wicks, especially without burning your fingers on the flame.
Some candle lighters have curved or flexible necks. A Piezo spark usually ignites cheap candle lighters, but there are some electric arc candle lighters too.
They share the same pros/cons as their parent type of lighter.
Check On Amazon
9. Pipe Lighters
Pipes can be difficult to light with traditional lighters; the flame can burn your fingers when you turn it upside down towards the pipe.
Pipe lighters solve this by changing the design of the lighter. Instead of having the flame come out of the top, the flame comes out of the side of the lighter. In other designs, the flame is encased in metal so it can be pointed down into a pipe.
Most pipe lighters are butane sparkweel lighters. Sometimes butane torch lighters are also called pipe lighters because the intense flame can be easily directed into a pipe.
They share the same features and pros/cons as Piezo lighters.
Check On Amazon
https://www.reddit.com/r/EDC/comments/4yq8vm/pros_and_cons_of_a_zippo/
https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/items/torch-lighters#:~:text=Torch%20lighters%20create%20a%20thin,at%20which%20it%20is%20held.
https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/gadgets/a31133313/how-plasma-lighters-work/
Good Information
Thank You!
Thanks for the info. I have a slim round barrel lighter, 18″ long, with a chain on one end and the flint on the other which is covered with a cap. Not sure if I can attach a pic here, but I’m having a hard time finding any information on it. I’m inclined to think that it might be vintage but not totally sure. Any info you could provide would be much appreciated! Thanks in advance!
Unfortunatley, I am not sure what that is. You can’t post pictures here but you can post links to pictures.
thanks man, a very thorough look at lighters that is random but extremely helpful