As I write this, the coronavirus pandemic is getting exponentially more widespread every day. In an effort to protect themselves from the virus, everyone wants a face mask, especially an N95 respirator which are said to provide the best protection against getting sick.
The problem is N95 respirators are now impossible to find. Read more about N95 Masks.
Luckily, it is possible to make your own respirator. The key is using a HEPA vacuum cleaner bag as a filter.
Watch on Video
Did COVID-19 catch you by surprise?
Don’t get caught unprepared again. In Disaster Preparedness for Women, you’ll learn how to get ready for any disaster in 52 sensible steps.
Why Make a DIY Respirator Mask?
Aside from the obvious reason that there are no N95 respirators left, here are some other reasons to make your own face respirator:
- Get a better fit: Studies regularly show that respirator masks only work well if they have a tight fit. Most masks on the market don’t fit children well or people with beards. If you do have an N95 mask and a beard, it’s time to shave!
- Moral obligation: Using a DIY mask means N95 masks are available to healthcare workers who need them on the frontlines of a pandemic.
- Provide for family and friends: In the Primal Survivor FB group for women, a lot of ladies talked about how they have “prepper’s guilt”; They had stockpiled supplies like N95 respirators for their family ahead of time, and now friends were asking for “donations.” Instead of giving them respirators from your supply, you could make a mask for them.
Do Homemade Face Masks Actually Protect Against Viruses?
All sorts of instructions for DIY virus face masks have come up lately. One of the most humorous ones I saw used a bra to make a mask. Others utilize designs where you can put a tissue between two layers of fabric.
But do these DIY masks actually work?
Studies show that DIY masks do provide protection, but the protection is minimal. N95 respirators provide the most protection followed by surgical masks. DIY masks provided less protection than surgical masks. (Source)
Mask Material Matters!
In the studies which tested DIY face masks, materials like tea cloths or dish towels were used. Not surprisingly, tea cloths allow a lot of airborne contaminants (including viruses) to pass through.
By contrast, some materials work much better for DIY respirators. A 2006 guidebook by the Institute of Medicine and Committee on the Development of Reusable Facemasks for Use During an Influenza Pandemic addressed this. While they are hesitant to recommend homemade masks because they might offer the wearer a false sense of security, they do say that:
The tighter the structure of the fabric, the better the potential for filtration… The level of protection offered also may be contingent on the tightness of the fit of the device to the wearer’s face.
For example, tests have found that tight-fitting six-layer gauze masks reduce contamination with tuberculosis bacilli by 90% to 95%. This is much more protection than you’d get wearing a mask made from a few layers of loose-fitting gauze.
Wearing any mask is better protection than no mask, but you’ll get better protection if you make a mask from the right material and size it for a tight fit.
Which Material is Best for Homemade Respirators?
N95 respirator masks are designed out of a non-woven material which can filter 95% of airborne contaminants of 0.3 microns or larger. The coronavirus is approximately 0.120 microns (or 120nm) in diameter (Source).
So, it would seem that the coronavirus could just get through the mask.
However, the material in N95 respirators does NOT work like “sieve” filters. Instead of catching large particles and allowing smaller ones to go through, N95 respirators actually work by tangling pathogens in their fibers.
As the IOM and Committee guidebook said,
“Respirator and medical mask filters are typically composed of mats of nonwoven fibrous materials, such as wool felt, fiberglass paper, or polypropylene. The material creates a tortuous path, and various mechanisms result in the adhesion of particles to the fibers without necessarily blocking the open spaces, still allowing air to flow easily across the filter.”
HEPA Material as an Alternative to N95 Masks
The material used to make HEPA vacuum bags has a lot of similar characteristics to N95 masks.
- Remove 99.7% of airborne particles down to 0.3 microns which pass through them
- Are made of a mat of randomly-arranged melt-blown fibers
- Trap contaminants through diffusion, interception, and impaction
There obviously isn’t any data on how well a HEPA vacuum bag works for preventing viral infection, but HEPA bags do seem to be the best choice of material if you are going to make a homemade face mask.
How to Make a Respirator from a HEPA Vacuum Bag
While I’m not a sewing expert, I was able to make lots of DIY N95 masks out of HEPA vacuum bags. Depending on the size of the bags and your face, you can get 2-3 masks per vacuum bag.
Don’t wear a HEPA vacuum bag directly against your skin.
HEPA vacuum bags have fiberglass threads inside of them. The fibers are large so aren’t dangerous like fiberglass dust. However, you could still breathe them in, which could cause airway irritation (Source).
Kind of ironic if your face mask made you start coughing during the midst of coronavirus.
Instead, you must use the HEPA vacuum bag as a filter inside a cloth mask.
- Fabric for the front of your mask, approximately 12×7 inches
- Liner fabric for the back of the mask, also 12×7 inches
- Elastic to secure the mask in place
- HEPA vacuum bag – They are readily available on Amazon
- A flat piece of flexible metal for the nose piece (optional but recommended)
1. Cut Out Fabric
- Iron your fabric first.
- Print and cut out the pattern. Get the pattern here (free PDF download). Make sure you print it to scale.
- Fold your front fabric in half. The back of the fabric should be facing outwards
- Pin the mask pattern to the back of your fabric or trace it using pencil.
- Cut out the fabric, making sure to LEAVE A ¼ INCH SEAM ALLOWANCE around the edges.
- Repeat for the liner fabric
2. Cut HEPA bag
- Remove the cardboard portion from the bag
- Trace or pin the HEPA pattern onto the bag
- Cut out the bag. *You only need to leave a seam allowance for the center line (the curved line which will go vertical down the face)
3. Sew the Center Line
Yes, I chose ridiculous fabric!
- Line up your first two fabric pieces with the backside facing outwards
- Pin the center line
- Sew the center line with a ¼ inch seam allowance
- Repeat for the liner fabric pieces.
4. Sew Front Fabric and Liner Fabric Together
- Open the fabric pieces you just sew
- Line up the fabric pieces so the backside is facing out and pin together
- Sew the sides and top of the mask together using a ¼ inch seam allowance. Do NOT sew the bottom side of the mask! You will need it to be open to insert the filter.
- When you are done, flip the mask so the fabric is right-side out
5. Sew and Insert HEPA Material
- Sew the center line of the pieces of HEPA filter you cut out, leaving a ¼ inch seam allowance. It’s probably best to do this by hand as it can snag on a sewing machine.
- Insert the HEPA material between the inside and outside layers of the mask
6. Sew Bottom Edge of Mask
- Turn ¼ inch of the bottom fabric under and pin in place.
- The two bottom edges together. I did this by hand using an overcast stitch
*If you want to make a “pocket mask” so you can remove the filter, you can instead close the bottom edge of the mask with tape. I haven’t tried this though so am not sure whether the bulkiness of the tape would affect how snugly the mask fits around the face. If anyone has advice on how to do a pocket mask, please let us know!
7. Attach Elastic
*Most DIY face masks have elastic ear bands. I find ear bands very uncomfortable. They also make it impossible to get a snug fit on the mask. This method of attaching elastic works much better.
- Fold over the side edges of the mask and sew them in place to make channels.
- The fold should be at least as wide as you elastic.
- Thread one long piece of elastic UP through the channel you just made. Then thread it DOWN through the channel on the opposite side.
- Tie the elastic. You now have top and bottom straps.
8. Attach Metal Nose Piece
If you have a flexible piece of metal, you can sew or glue it to the top of the respirator. This will provide a better fit so air doesn’t leak into the mask.
What to use as a nose piece:
- Pipe cleaners
- Wire twisted in a loop and wrapped in duct tape (so it doesn’t scratch you/poke your eye out)
- Stripped down copper wire
- Grocery store twist ties
- The metal closures on coffee bags
- Metal strip on manila envelopes
- Paper clip, with ends sanded down
- Metal pie tin, folded so no sharp edges are exposed
- Piece of a soda can, with edges sanded or hammered down so they aren’t sharp
- The underwire of a bra
Reusing Homemade Respirators during a Viral Pandemic
N95 respirators are supposed to be disposable. However, even the CDC acknowledges that they may have to be reused when in short supply. If you need to reuse an N95 respirator (or your DIY respirator), follow these guidelines:
- Wash your hands before and after putting on the respirator or adjusting it. Or use hand sanitizer if you can’t wash your hands.
- Avoid touching inside the respirator.
- Don’t try to disinfect respirators. Disinfectants like alcohol and bleach can damage the respirator’s structural integrity. This also applies to HEPA vacuum bags.
- When not using the respirator, store in a breathable bag. Paper bags work for this.
- Have enough respirators for at least 4 days. The coronavirus can live on surfaces for 3 days. If you make enough respirators for 4 days, then you can cycle through respirators. For example, if you go out 2x per day, you’ll want to have 6 masks so you have enough for each outing over 4 days.
Cleaning a Homemade Respirator Mask
Can you wash this mask? The short answer is I don’t know. HEPA vacuum bags are designed to be disposable and there haven’t been any tests about what happens to the filter medium when washed.
However, there were studies which tested methods of cleaning N95 respirators. It found that: An autoclave, 160°C dry heat, 70% isopropyl alcohol, bleach, and soap and water (20-min soak) caused significant degradation to filtration efficiency.
Because of this, I do NOT recommend cleaning/washing the HEPA filter medium. Instead, cycle through the masks as talked about in the section above.
If you are worried about keeping the exterior fabric clean, you could wear a shield of bandana over the mask. Or, if you are crafty, turn this design into a “pocket mask” so the filter can be removed and the fabric portion cleaned. Remember the filter will still have to be set aside for at least 3 days so any viruses on it have time to die off.
I’m not a doctor or an epidemiologist. I can’t guarantee that this DIY respirator will protect you from any virus. However, the research has shown that any mask is better than no mask. Based on what I know about HEPA materials, it seems to be the best filter for a DIY mask- certainly better than the tissues being used in many DIY masks!
Have you made your own N95 mask? Tell us about it in the comments.